Loop antenna vs long wire
Posts: 813
Threads: 49
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Shenandoah,
State, Province, Country: Pennsylvania
Hey guys and gals, I was wondering about the benefits of a loop antenna. I have a Philco 37-116 running off a long wire antenna and while it picks up many stations, it seems to also pick up a lot of noise and static compared to my 41-250 with a built in loop antenna! Just about every station on th41-250 is quieter than the same station on the 37-116 except for strong local ones. The long wire antenna is outside away from power lines and machinery. Would like to build a loop antenna for the 37-116.
Ron
Bendix 0626. RCA 8BX5. RCA T64
Philco 41-250. Philco49-500
GE 201. Philco 39-25
Motorola 61X13. Philco 46-42 Crosley 52TQ
Philco 37-116. Philco 70
AK 35 Philco 46-350
Philco 620B. Zenith Transoceanic B-600
Philco 60B. Majestic 50
Philco 52-944. AK 84
Posts: 2,118
Threads: 112
Joined: Jun 2010
City: Medford OR (OR what?)
The variable IF setting on the 37-116 will make a difference. Set it for narrow to eliminate some of the noise.
"I just might turn into smoke, but I feel fine"
http://www.russoldradios.com/
Posts: 813
Threads: 49
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Shenandoah,
State, Province, Country: Pennsylvania
Thanks Phlo, yes the variable IF does help some but my set with the loop antenna still seems quieter. I know Philco had a special loop antenna for the 37-116 so I would like to try a fabricate something similar if I had the specs and dimensions of one.
Bendix 0626. RCA 8BX5. RCA T64
Philco 41-250. Philco49-500
GE 201. Philco 39-25
Motorola 61X13. Philco 46-42 Crosley 52TQ
Philco 37-116. Philco 70
AK 35 Philco 46-350
Philco 620B. Zenith Transoceanic B-600
Philco 60B. Majestic 50
Philco 52-944. AK 84
Posts: 13,776
Threads: 580
Joined: Sep 2005
City: Ferdinand
State, Province, Country: Indiana
(03-21-2015, 10:00 PM)462ron Wrote: I know Philco had a special loop antenna for the 37-116...
No, they didn't. They had a special outdoor doublet antenna for the 37-116 and other 1937 Philco models. It was called the Philco High Efficiency Aerial.
http://www.philcorepairbench.com/mystery/40-6112.htm
http://www.philcoradio.com/phorum/showth...hp?tid=297
--
Ron Ramirez
Ferdinand IN
Posts: 813
Threads: 49
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Shenandoah,
State, Province, Country: Pennsylvania
Thanks much Ron! My mistake, thought they had a loop antenna for consoles. Interesting threads on these antennae. I will need to do some experimenting, I was just surprised to hear how much quieter my 41-250 was. A guy at K-town a few years ago said something to me about it being a low impedance antenna that made it less susceptible to external noise and interference.
Ron
Bendix 0626. RCA 8BX5. RCA T64
Philco 41-250. Philco49-500
GE 201. Philco 39-25
Motorola 61X13. Philco 46-42 Crosley 52TQ
Philco 37-116. Philco 70
AK 35 Philco 46-350
Philco 620B. Zenith Transoceanic B-600
Philco 60B. Majestic 50
Philco 52-944. AK 84
Posts: 1,191
Threads: 25
Joined: Jan 2014
City: Wellborn Florida
Joe Carr has written several books on the subject one is free on line as a pdf. Several of his books can be purchased from amazon lots of fun projects! David
Posts: 813
Threads: 49
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Shenandoah,
State, Province, Country: Pennsylvania
Thanks David, Found the Book in PDF format and downloaded it. Now to get the time and read it.
Bendix 0626. RCA 8BX5. RCA T64
Philco 41-250. Philco49-500
GE 201. Philco 39-25
Motorola 61X13. Philco 46-42 Crosley 52TQ
Philco 37-116. Philco 70
AK 35 Philco 46-350
Philco 620B. Zenith Transoceanic B-600
Philco 60B. Majestic 50
Philco 52-944. AK 84
Posts: 181
Threads: 0
Joined: Mar 2008
City: Pocasset, MA
A shielded loop can be insensitive to electrostatic fields (local RFI), but an unshielded one acts like a short vertical antenna.
The other useful property of a loop is nulling a signal broadside to it (the signal generates equal voltages in the two vertical sides of the loop, which cancel out). Balancing the feed well enough to achieve this is tricky however.
Posts: 1,114
Threads: 14
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Irvington, NY
Yes, the shielded loop can be very effective in reducing pickup from locally generated interference. That may be the effect you are noticing when comparing the long wire of the 37-116 to the low impedance loop of the 41-250.
In the 1940 models, Philco used a loop antenna with an electrostatic shield. This was a Faraday shield composed of a large number of grounded wires imbedded in the cardboard covering of the rotatable loop.
In the 1941 and later models, Philco used a different approach. They designed the loop with only a few turns of very heavy wire, and used a tuned antenna matching transformer to step up the impedance to the grid of the front end tube. Because of the low impedance of the actual loop antenna, it was relatively insensitive to the electrostatic fields of locally generated interference, yet still responded directionally to the transmitted electromagnetic field of the more distant broadcast radio signals.
https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=paten...322126.pdf
(This post was last modified: 03-23-2015, 09:51 PM by Mondial.)
Posts: 813
Threads: 49
Joined: Feb 2013
City: Shenandoah,
State, Province, Country: Pennsylvania
Thanks Mondial, that link looks like something I would like to experiment with. I have the chassis for my 37-116 completed but the cabinet needs work yet. So eventually when it is done and I finally get the radio installed into the cabinet I am going to try a loop on it. Thnks agan.
Ron
Bendix 0626. RCA 8BX5. RCA T64
Philco 41-250. Philco49-500
GE 201. Philco 39-25
Motorola 61X13. Philco 46-42 Crosley 52TQ
Philco 37-116. Philco 70
AK 35 Philco 46-350
Philco 620B. Zenith Transoceanic B-600
Philco 60B. Majestic 50
Philco 52-944. AK 84
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
|
Recent Posts
|
12' Philco
|
If it is 12', either Kareem or Andre would have to jump pretty high to look at the front panel.
Kareem would have an e...morzh — 01:48 PM |
12' Philco
|
And here's a story about the tires on the truck. Same "no-stoop" guy must have installed these! Take care a...GarySP — 01:17 PM |
Hickok AC51 tube tester
|
I think they have only shown the secondaries of the transformer.
Two of them feed the rectifiers' filaments.morzh — 12:58 PM |
IF can wire size and Rubber mounts?
|
Arran
If the wire inside cans is the gauges you mentioned, the sole reason for that would be mechanical, to stiffen t...morzh — 12:56 PM |
12' Philco
|
Rod,
Yes, I know, but the Giant Philco is not around anymore either, so I go by whoever was alive fairly recently.
H...morzh — 12:54 PM |
Hickok AC51 tube tester
|
Absolutely no one is going to reverse engineer that circuit. Even the iron core is missing.RodB — 10:37 AM |
IF can wire size and Rubber mounts?
|
Thanks to both members for your help regarding wire and tuner mtg supports. regards--Johngeorgetownjohn — 09:33 AM |
Hickok AC51 tube tester
|
Note that no power cord, power switch, or power transformer switch are shown. That (along with my experience with full s...DaleHCook — 07:09 AM |
IF can wire size and Rubber mounts?
|
A pair of wire strippers can give you an idea of what the existing gauge of the wire leads are in the IF can, I think it...Arran — 06:07 AM |
My last cabinet for this year
|
Hello Dan,
That is really beautiful what great looking radio you have !
I have friends who live in Calgary and the wea...radiorich — 01:51 AM |
Who's Online
|
There are currently no members online. |
|
|