Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Permanent Magnet as a Philco Replacement Speaker?
#1

I recently acquired a Philco model 38-5 tombstone that is missing the speaker. I have placed requests in the "Wanted" sections of various radio sites but have come up empty. As a temporary solution I would like to install a permanent magnet speaker until I someday find an original. While I've restored a quite a few radios in my time I have never had to replace an electrodynamic speaker with a permanent magnet type and am unsure how to proceed.

I'm missing:

- the output transformer
- the field coil

(are the output transformer and the field coil the same thing?)

- the voice coil

I've done some searching and it sounds like using a choke of the appropriate rating is preferred to using a resistor and bumping up the capacity of the filters when replacing the field coil so I'd like to go that route.

In the absence of the original speaker how can I determine what the voice coil resistance is?

I'm not even sure how to begin Icon_redface. Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks,
Geoff
#2

The Model 38-5 used two speakers, one in the table top, or B cabinet and another in the console, or X cabinet.

The B cabinet uses a Model H-29 speaker.
The X cabinet uses a Model K-39 speaker.


Both speakers have the same field coil which has a D.C.
resistance of 660 ohms. Both also have the same voice
coil impedance of approximately 2 ohms at 400 Hz.

A PM speaker of 4-8 ohms should work just fine however.
A replacement power resistor to sub for the field coil can
be a 680 ohm, 10 watt unit to run cool.
This is assuming a max current of 90 mA.

Alternatively, you could starts looking for a H-29 or K-39 to fill the bill.

The Model 38-3 and 38-4 also used the H-29 speaker.
#3

Thanks for the info Chuck. I posted the same question elsewhere and got some good follow up:

http://antiqueradios.com/forums/Forum11/...07746.html

I also noticed in the schematic that the 38-4 console uses the same chassis with an H 29 speaker (my table top model 38-5 uses the K 39). There is an H 29 speaker on eBay right now but at 11" I think it would be too big for the table top model. And from the description it sounds like it has been modified:

http://cgi.ebay.com/6619460062

There is also this H 21 speaker but I'm not sure if this would work for my application:

http://cgi.ebay.com/6619301772

Regards,
Geoff
#4

Yes, that's the differeence between the two speakers, just the size; smaller one in the table-top cabinet, but with same electrical specs.




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
[-]
Recent Posts
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
I remember a bakelite "lampshade" (a fancy lampshade) style plug being available in the hardware store when I ...MrFixr55 — 10:39 AM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Hello Arran Yes, I also like the lampshade style plug ! Sincerely Richardradiorich — 08:46 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Hello morzh, Nice explanation on the x and y capacitors and glad you are narrowing down the issue with this set ! Si...radiorich — 08:43 AM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
From what I read Philco went to using brown rubber power cords in 1936, so cloth was used in the 1935 and earlier models...Arran — 11:25 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Hi Bruce, I have not worked on an 84, but in general, power cords for almost any radio prior to 1938 was cloth covered...MrFixr55 — 08:34 PM
Restoring Philco 38-14
OK, well, so after staring at the sch again, I realized the problem had to be the #12/12A padder. I put a scope on the o...morzh — 08:15 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Hello Bruce, I mostly use brown far as my cloth powercords go ! Here is the plug that I have used bakelite Acorn style...radiorich — 08:05 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Looking for as correct as can find the right Ac plug an the correct colored cloth line. Ive seen many old photos but mos...Bruce — 04:13 PM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Rod Two Y-caps make sense if you use them from L/N to the chassis; this is only makes sense in the transformer radios w...morzh — 10:11 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Mike, I'm curious about a specific use of he Y cap. Lately I've seen a single cap across the power transformer primary. ...RodB — 09:01 AM

[-]
Who's Online
There are currently 2920 online users. [Complete List]
» 1 Member(s) | 2919 Guest(s)
Avatar

>