Welcome Guest! Be sure you know and follow the Phorum Rules before posting. Thank you and Enjoy! (January 12) x

Thread Closed
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Permanent Magnet as a Philco Replacement Speaker?
#1

I recently acquired a Philco model 38-5 tombstone that is missing the speaker. I have placed requests in the "Wanted" sections of various radio sites but have come up empty. As a temporary solution I would like to install a permanent magnet speaker until I someday find an original. While I've restored a quite a few radios in my time I have never had to replace an electrodynamic speaker with a permanent magnet type and am unsure how to proceed.

I'm missing:

- the output transformer
- the field coil

(are the output transformer and the field coil the same thing?)

- the voice coil

I've done some searching and it sounds like using a choke of the appropriate rating is preferred to using a resistor and bumping up the capacity of the filters when replacing the field coil so I'd like to go that route.

In the absence of the original speaker how can I determine what the voice coil resistance is?

I'm not even sure how to begin Icon_redface. Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks,
Geoff
#2

The Model 38-5 used two speakers, one in the table top, or B cabinet and another in the console, or X cabinet.

The B cabinet uses a Model H-29 speaker.
The X cabinet uses a Model K-39 speaker.


Both speakers have the same field coil which has a D.C.
resistance of 660 ohms. Both also have the same voice
coil impedance of approximately 2 ohms at 400 Hz.

A PM speaker of 4-8 ohms should work just fine however.
A replacement power resistor to sub for the field coil can
be a 680 ohm, 10 watt unit to run cool.
This is assuming a max current of 90 mA.

Alternatively, you could starts looking for a H-29 or K-39 to fill the bill.

The Model 38-3 and 38-4 also used the H-29 speaker.
#3

Thanks for the info Chuck. I posted the same question elsewhere and got some good follow up:

http://antiqueradios.com/forums/Forum11/...07746.html

I also noticed in the schematic that the 38-4 console uses the same chassis with an H 29 speaker (my table top model 38-5 uses the K 39). There is an H 29 speaker on eBay right now but at 11" I think it would be too big for the table top model. And from the description it sounds like it has been modified:

http://cgi.ebay.com/6619460062

There is also this H 21 speaker but I'm not sure if this would work for my application:

http://cgi.ebay.com/6619301772

Regards,
Geoff
#4

Yes, that's the differeence between the two speakers, just the size; smaller one in the table-top cabinet, but with same electrical specs.




Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
[-]
Recent Posts
An attempt to remove the Field Coil from a G speaker
Mike; I've only run into a speaker with an open filed coil twice, and they were on newer speakers from the 1940s. One ...Arran — 12:48 AM
An attempt to remove the Field Coil from a G speaker
Arran Yes, this is my plan for now and what do I got to lose, this is not even the speaker from this radio, but one o...morzh — 10:44 PM
An attempt to remove the Field Coil from a G speaker
Mike;  I would unwrap the field coil, and see if maybe there a break near one of the ends, like where the coil wire att...Arran — 10:23 PM
An attempt to remove the Field Coil from a G speaker
...and this is what I did. I fed a little LT into the screwholes with a small brush, and a little on the rim next to the...morzh — 09:52 PM
Philco 40-120C Restoration
I combined the two 40-120C threads together as we like to keep the discussion of the same radio together. It helps with...klondike98 — 09:36 PM
Philco 40-120C Weak, Distorted Ouput
Just checked were I buy tubes price is four dollars. So living in Florid we have a local source for tubes. David    David — 09:14 PM
Philco 40-120C Weak, Distorted Ouput
The higher voltage may be due to higher mains voltage. My mains run 120-125AC when the set was new mains would be 110-11...David — 09:09 PM
Philco 40-120C Weak, Distorted Ouput
Thank you for your reply. I pulled a speaker from a Philco 41-221 and received the same result. I used a signal tracer t...bluecap — 08:45 PM
Philco 40-120C Weak, Distorted Ouput
Have you tried a different speaker? How did you trace the distortion? How do you know it is weak? What is the reference?...morzh — 08:33 PM
Philco 46-480 Electronic Restoration
Amen to that! Every time I think I’ve captured them all, I realize that there’s another error. My goal is to finish with...jrblasde — 07:00 PM

[-]
Who's Online
There are currently no members online.

>