Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Metal Film vs. Carbon film resistors
#1

Are there specific applications for the two types, or is it a matter of personal preference between these resistors?

I have been buying the metal film type. Now I am in need of some 75K and 750K which I have found at Mouser. So I am wondering which to get.

Thanks for any input.

Gene
#2

metal film is good and cheaper than carbon.
I like metal oxide as it is the cheapest and at 5% tolerance has the highest working temp up to 200 C (metal film - up to 155C). Metal film has better stability over temperature.
#3

I've noticed that often one is cheaper then the other depending on the resistance value, both are far cheaper then carbon comp resistors though.
Supposedly they also have voltage ratings, but I have never had a 1/2 Watter arc over in any radio that I repaired so I guess the 400 v rating is high enough.
Regards
Arran
#4

Thanks for the replies!

Gene
#5

Standard 1/2 metal film are rated for 350 volts, but you can also get them at 500 and 700 for about the same price.

Here is Mouser's selection of 1/2W, 700v metal film resistors.
http://www.mouser.com/Passive-Components...pyZ1z0x85h




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
[-]
Recent Posts
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
From what I read Philco went to using brown rubber power cords in 1936, so cloth was used in the 1935 and earlier models...Arran — 11:25 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Hi Bruce, I have not worked on an 84, but in general, power cords for almost any radio prior to 1938 was cloth covered...MrFixr55 — 08:34 PM
Restoring Philco 38-14
OK, well, so after staring at the sch again, I realized the problem had to be the #12/12A padder. I put a scope on the o...morzh — 08:15 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Hello Bruce, I mostly use brown far as my cloth powercords go ! Here is the plug that I have used bakelite Acorn style...radiorich — 08:05 PM
Correct model 84 Ac plug an cord type
Looking for as correct as can find the right Ac plug an the correct colored cloth line. Ive seen many old photos but mos...Bruce — 04:13 PM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Rod Two Y-caps make sense if you use them from L/N to the chassis; this is only makes sense in the transformer radios...morzh — 10:11 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Mike, I'm curious about a specific use of he Y cap. Lately I've seen a single cap across the power transformer primary. ...RodB — 09:01 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
hello morzh , That sounds like a plan ! Sincerely Richardradiorich — 07:45 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Richard, It helped some, but I still had the whining when engaging the rear power strip (I did not realize it was fro...morzh — 07:07 AM
Restoring Philco 38-14
Hello morzh, Yes , that dreaded hum in my room where i do alighment I have my cable modem and router plus desktop plus ...radiorich — 11:25 PM

[-]
Who's Online
There are currently 4409 online users. [Complete List]
» 1 Member(s) | 4408 Guest(s)
Avatar

>