Welcome Guest! Be sure you know and follow the Phorum Rules before posting. Thank you and Enjoy! (January 12, 2025) x

Thread Closed

Replacing a Field Coil with a PM Speaker - Please Help
#12

As Arran said, "Though you can get away with using a resistor in a Pi filter arrangement in a 4 tuber like a model 84, and it will work fine if you use larger filter capacitors to compensate for the lower inductance".

Now, about increasing capacitances.

Your 80 tube can handle up to 32uF direct capacitive load, so you should not be exceeding that. Go say 20uF for starters.
This will 1) decrease ripple and 2) increase the output voltage some but then some of it will be lost on your resistor as you might want to go a bit higher.

Then the resistor. Go at least with the value of your field coil loss resistance which is 1.14 kOhm.
Then choose your second cap from the ratio

R*C >> 1/60, where R is in Ohms, C is in Farads, and the results are in seconds.
So if your resistance is roughly 1K, your output cap ideally should be 160uF.

This is a bit too much, as this kind of cap will be too large and expensive. However if you go with say 2K resistor and 47uF (50uF) 500V cap you will stay within size and fairly low cost. And the time constant is still acceptable.

Choose your resistance wattage so it could handle whatever the voltage drop you will measure, formula V-square/R for dissipated and two-three times that for rating of the resistor so it does not self destruct too soon.
Or if you know your current consumption in advance, go I-square * R for the dissipated (same as above for rated).

You will need to experiment a bit to see if your output voltage is the same or close to recommended; should not be much lower or much higher.

------------------


This said, the choke is still a preferred solution.


Messages In This Thread
RE: Replacing a Field Coil with a PM Speaker - Please Help - by morzh - 04-16-2014, 10:52 AM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
[-]
Recent Posts
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
Hello Roy, here is this one sincerely Richardradiorich — 12:45 AM
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
Richard, Had grabbed it already but thank you just the same.  I find myself wanting to find some way to block out the...glyphmon — 12:03 AM
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
Hello roy, here is a link to the schematic . Sincerely Richardradiorich — 11:54 PM
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
Richard, The Silvertone 2014 also is a transformerless set, so I am incorporating a 1:1 600 ohm audio isolation transfo...glyphmon — 11:37 PM
Preliminary work on wife's Silvertone 2014
Did an alignment today which was interesting.  IF alignment went great, almost all was already spot-on.  Adjusting on th...glyphmon — 11:35 PM
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
The main problem with adding a Bluetooth input is that this set lacks a traditional power transformer to isolate it from...radiorich — 11:19 PM
54C Cabinet Refinish
I started stripping this cabinet before it got super chilly out because I knew I wasn't going to be able to work on ...glyphmon — 11:18 PM
54C Complete Teardown/Rebuild
While I'm waiting to wrap up the final steps on my wife's Silvertone 2014, I started disassembly on the next project.  O...glyphmon — 11:07 PM
Preliminary work on wife's Silvertone 2014
Hello roy, that great news glad it worked out for you !! Sincerely Richardradiorich — 10:50 PM
Preliminary work on wife's Silvertone 2014
Safety caps arrived today.  Soldered one in and had a successful first power-up.  No magic smoke escaped and it tunes in...glyphmon — 09:53 PM

[-]
Who's Online
There are currently 1520 online users. [Complete List]
» 1 Member(s) | 1519 Guest(s)
Avatar

>