Welcome Guest! Be sure you know and follow the Phorum Rules before posting. Thank you and Enjoy! (January 12) x

Thread Closed
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Metal Film vs. Carbon film resistors
#1

Are there specific applications for the two types, or is it a matter of personal preference between these resistors?

I have been buying the metal film type. Now I am in need of some 75K and 750K which I have found at Mouser. So I am wondering which to get.

Thanks for any input.

Gene
#2

metal film is good and cheaper than carbon.
I like metal oxide as it is the cheapest and at 5% tolerance has the highest working temp up to 200 C (metal film - up to 155C). Metal film has better stability over temperature.
#3

I've noticed that often one is cheaper then the other depending on the resistance value, both are far cheaper then carbon comp resistors though.
Supposedly they also have voltage ratings, but I have never had a 1/2 Watter arc over in any radio that I repaired so I guess the 400 v rating is high enough.
Regards
Arran
#4

Thanks for the replies!

Gene
#5

Standard 1/2 metal film are rated for 350 volts, but you can also get them at 500 and 700 for about the same price.

Here is Mouser's selection of 1/2W, 700v metal film resistors.
http://www.mouser.com/Passive-Components...pyZ1z0x85h




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
[-]
Recent Posts
Philco model 40-100
That was part pf what began my interest in tube battery radios, the variety of circuit designs, especially by Grimes-Pho...Arran — 02:37 PM
Studebaker/Philco AC-2687 car radio
Phill; I had a look at my Riders "Specialized" car radio books yesterday, I don't have one that covers Stud...Arran — 01:50 PM
Philco Model 249 made in England
Thanks for the information MrFixr55.   It's tube amplification and not solid state. TOMfklown — 11:27 AM
Philco Model 249 made in England
Well, I’ll be! I learned something.jrblasde — 11:03 AM
Philco Model 249 made in England
Yes, Garrard was well-regarded for its standalones.morzh — 10:48 AM
Philco 46-480 Electronic Restoration
Quite the interesting stories, sir! Somewhat reminds me of my first job out of school (not that I worked in a similar fi...jrblasde — 09:33 AM
Philco model 40-100
Arran, I restored 2 Canadian battery-crank telephones for a friend a while ago, a Northern Electric (Canadian version of...MrFixr55 — 08:04 AM
Road Trip for a Philco 46-480
Beautiful work, a 79 year old radio brought back to life. The first FM radios for me, a little iffy, had some I just cou...Jimradio — 08:01 AM
Philco 46-480 Electronic Restoration
I was a field engineer for a biomedical company for many years. Many was the time that I was driving home from NYC in t...MrFixr55 — 06:40 AM
Philco 46-480 Electronic Restoration
Don't laugh folks, I have not been above taking a chassis into the bathtub (when Ms. Fixr was out of the house), taping ...MrFixr55 — 06:02 AM

[-]
Who's Online
There are currently 1168 online users. [Complete List]
» 1 Member(s) | 1167 Guest(s)
Avatar

>