Mullard tube$ from Blackburn - your thoughts
Posts: 1,130
Threads: 79
Joined: Jan 2014
City: Annapolis, IL
In searching for some tubes for my Fisher, I am a little puzzled about the cost of the older 6BQ5 tubes made in England, esp at the Blackburn plant. I wonder what is so special about them to drive such a high price, even for well used tubes. Can someone more Hi Fi savvy than myself enlighten me?
I can remember pulling a set of these out of an old VM "Hi Fi" record player and thinking they were bad since they looked all black and burned up - needless to say, they weren't the problem, and unfortunately are long gone, along with the record player by about 40 years . (and yes, I robbed the pic from Ebay)
If I could find the place called "Somewhere", I could find "Anything"
Tim
Jesus cried out and said, "Whoever believes in me , believes not in me but in him who sent me" John 12:44
Posts: 244
Threads: 11
Joined: Oct 2011
City: Black Mountain, NC
Since Ron doesn't have an hi-fi audio section take a look over at AudioKarma in the Tube Audio section. After a while the term Audiophool will become clear.
Thanks,
Mike
Cossor 3468
GE 417A
Philco 118H
Radiola 17/100
Scott 800B6
Silvertone 6130
Stromberg 535M
Truetone D1952
Posts: 2,118
Threads: 112
Joined: Jun 2010
City: Medford OR (OR what?)
No. But there is a significant difference in the 7189 and especially the 7189A which are higher voltage variants.
"I just might turn into smoke, but I feel fine"
http://www.russoldradios.com/
Posts: 4,377
Threads: 411
Joined: Jun 2011
City: Boston
State, Province, Country: Massachusetts
The 6BQ5 is listed in one of the ads here...
http://vintagetubeservices.com/mullard-products-tour/
These things have followings, and probably drives the price as much as it's performance.
Paul
Tubetalk1
Posts: 4,682
Threads: 51
Joined: Sep 2008
City: Sandwick, BC, CA
What justifies the price? Absolutely nothing but audiophools thinking that an EL84/6BQ5 made in a Phillips owned subsidiary, in Britain, using Phillips machinery, manufacturing Phillips designed tubes to Phillips manufacturing specs, with a label saying "Mullard" in water soluble paint rather then "Phillips" makes them better tubes. So whether the label on the tube says Phillips, Valvo, Mullard, Rogers, or Amperex, (sorry can't remember the name of Phillips' French tube company) they are all the same tubes other then the label and the box. The only reason why people think that they are something special is because a lot of classic HiFi manufacturers used them, and that was because Mullard probably offered them for a cheaper price then RCA or Sylvania would have, and offered to print their name on them like those EICO branded 6BQ5s. But a refuse to believe that because a tube is made in Blackburn, England, rather then Eindhoven, in Holland, is better when it's the same company.
Regards
Arran
Posts: 4,682
Threads: 51
Joined: Sep 2008
City: Sandwick, BC, CA
(12-07-2015, 04:25 PM)Phlogiston Wrote: No. But there is a significant difference in the 7189 and especially the 7189A which are higher voltage variants.
Just like the diferences between a 6L6G, and a 6L6GB, 6L6GTB, and a 6L6GC, why they could not have come up with a new number entirely for each must have been related to marketing.
Regards
Arran
(This post was last modified: 12-08-2015, 02:46 AM by Arran.)
Posts: 1,130
Threads: 79
Joined: Jan 2014
City: Annapolis, IL
Thanks for the insight. There is some interesting reading about these tubes. Thanks for the website links! There may be some merit to all this, but I guess that depends a lot on your or my ears, equipment, and of course, budget. It sounds like I may want to search through my boxes of tubes for my old, original Fisher tubes that I replaced back when I first acquired my receiver.
If I could find the place called "Somewhere", I could find "Anything"
Tim
Jesus cried out and said, "Whoever believes in me , believes not in me but in him who sent me" John 12:44
Posts: 4,377
Threads: 411
Joined: Jun 2011
City: Boston
State, Province, Country: Massachusetts
Lots of good reasonbly priced tube sellers out there if you are willing to take a different brand.
paul
Tubetalk1
Posts: 2,128
Threads: 18
Joined: Oct 2008
City: Merrick, Long Island, NY
Agree, Mullard tubes were pretty well regarded then and now. But plenty of other good ones out there too. And yes, everybody made for everybody else. Just how many aspirin plants are there in the world?
Posts: 1,824
Threads: 114
Joined: Jul 2014
City: Sneedville, TN
From my own experience, any well matched set from a reputable manufacturer, whether Mullard, or Philips, or RCA, or Sylvania, will do fine for the push pull output, and that is the only place it makes a heck of a lot of difference, and, of course in the parallel - push pull combinations one needs a 4 match..Of course, in either case, after 6 months of use, the match won't be nearly as close anyway. For the single stages, as long as the tube is within spec it should be fine. More often any distortion problems are more likely due to aging parts whose values have shifted than what brand of tube one uses as long as they are in spec and decent tubes. There was a great deal of silly mythology and audio snobbery back in the tube days driven by manufacturer's hype, just as there is today.
Posts: 344
Threads: 38
Joined: Jun 2011
City: Tustin
State, Province, Country: California
Telefunken is another tube that commands a high price. I do like the Telefunken 12ax7's, 12au7's etc. as they seem to last forever. They were factory screened for 10,000 hour filament life. Many of the US "made for military" were great tubes as well.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2015, 10:43 PM by thirtiesradio.)
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
|
Recent Posts
|
Jackson 715 not working
|
Now that you posted the schematic, I don't know why that Sprague electrolytic cap is across the meter, as it is not indi...MrFixr55 — 05:51 PM |
HiFi (Chifi) tube amp build - but my own design.
|
What may be lacking in the PP Tube amps may be the 2nd harmonics, which some, especially RCA back in the day called &quo...MrFixr55 — 05:32 PM |
Jackson 715 not working
|
Usually in an emission tester, the tube under test is measured as if it were a diode. So, some testers connect all the g...RodB — 04:17 PM |
Restoring Philco 37-604C
|
Yep. F5 is green, D5 is Red.
Red is Bad.
Green is Clean.morzh — 01:30 PM |
Jackson 715 not working
|
I did start to do that but I stalled out because I could not figure out how the grid and plate get voltage. In this diag...daveone23 — 11:52 AM |
Restoring Philco 37-604C
|
(Insert Homer Simpson "DOPF" Here.)
When all fails, look at the can. Took the Ron Ramirez advice, red Caig D...MrFixr55 — 09:23 AM |
Philco 91 Speaker Replacement
|
From your text I am not sure if you intend to use the existing speaker with a resistor instead of the field coil.
It wo...morzh — 08:44 AM |
Philco 91 Speaker Replacement
|
My field coil is bad. I am still hoping to find an original, but if I can't I will go with a fitting Philco speaker, 125...dconant — 08:34 AM |
Philco 91 Speaker Replacement
|
As Rod said, it is OK to use a fitting speaker, and then look for an original one.
If you buy a Hammond 125 output tr...morzh — 08:15 AM |
Philco 91 Speaker Replacement
|
Yes, I often have to substitute, then keep an eye out for an original. In the meantime, the radio is working and being e...RodB — 08:02 AM |
Who's Online
|
There are currently no members online. |
|
|